• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy
Wednesday, October 22, 2025
Umpirenews | Latest News, Politics, Breaking News, Nigeria and African history
Advertisement
  • National
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Columns
No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Columns
No Result
View All Result
Umpirenews | Latest News, Politics, Breaking News, Nigeria and African history
No Result
View All Result

ECOWAS Court Dismisses SERAP’s Suit Over 2022 Kaduna Train Attack

Roland Bayode by Roland Bayode
November 15, 2024
in National
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
ECOWAS Court Dismisses SERAP’s Suit Over 2022 Kaduna Train Attack
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsappShare on EmailShare on Telegram


The ECOWAS Court has dismissed a lawsuit brought by the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) concerning the deadly Abuja-Kaduna train attack on March 28, 2022. The case, which aimed to hold the Nigerian government accountable for alleged human rights violations linked to the attack, was rejected on the grounds of jurisdictional and procedural deficiencies.


On the day of the incident, armed assailants bombed a passenger train carrying over 970 people on the Abuja-Kaduna rail line near Rigasa, Kaduna State. The attack resulted in numerous fatalities, injuries, and abductions, sparking national outrage and calls for greater security measures on critical transportation routes.

In response, SERAP filed a suit at the ECOWAS Court, arguing that the Nigerian government failed in its duty to protect the lives and safety of its citizens. The organization alleged that the lack of adequate security measures by the state violated the passengers’ fundamental rights to life, security, and dignity.


SERAP sought a court ruling that would mandate the Nigerian government to pay N50 million in compensation to each of the affected passengers and their families. The suit was grounded in the argument that the government’s negligence contributed to the severity of the attack and that the victims deserved redress for their suffering and losses. SERAP also aimed to highlight the broader issue of terrorism and insecurity affecting the region, citing similar attacks on educational institutions and public transportation as part of a pattern of state failure to protect citizens.


However, the ECOWAS Court, in its judgement delivered by Justice Dupe Atoki, ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the case as it was presented. The three-member panel, including presiding judge Justice Ricardo Cláudio Monteiro Gonçalves and panel member Justice Sengu Mohamed Koroma, found the claim inadmissible under the ECOWAS Supplementary Protocol’s legal framework. Specifically, the court referenced Article 10(d) of the protocol, which requires that a party bringing a case for human rights violations must meet certain victim status requirements.


The court acknowledged that while it has the authority to adjudicate potential human rights violations within member states under Article 9(4) of the ECOWAS Supplementary Protocol, SERAP’s case did not meet the criteria necessary for consideration as a public interest litigation.

The ECOWAS Court emphasized that public interest cases, or actio popularis, should typically address violations affecting a broad, indeterminate segment of the public or the general populace itself. In contrast, the victims of the train attack were specific, identifiable individuals, which did not satisfy the requirements for a public interest lawsuit.


The court elaborated on its decision, noting that SERAP’s demand for financial compensation was directed towards specific victims of the attack rather than the general public. This focus on identifiable individuals contradicted the nature of public interest litigation, which traditionally seeks broader societal impact rather than specific individual remedies.

The reliefs sought by SERAP, including the N50 million compensation per passenger, were thus deemed inappropriate for consideration under the procedural rules governing public interest actions.


The dismissal of the case has sparked discussions about the limitations of legal recourse available to civil society organizations like SERAP when challenging state actions or inactions related to security and human rights issues. It also underscores the stringent requirements for public interest litigation at the ECOWAS Court, particularly in cases involving identifiable victims rather than widespread, diffuse harm.


Despite the dismissal, the ruling does not negate the legitimacy of SERAP’s concerns about government accountability and the broader issue of insecurity in Nigeria. The Abuja-Kaduna train attack remains a significant event that has prompted calls for increased investment in security infrastructure and better protection of critical public services.

The Nigerian government’s response to such incidents and its overall approach to combating terrorism and banditry continue to be subjects of intense public scrutiny and debate.


The ruling also highlighted the importance of meeting procedural requirements when filing cases in regional courts like the ECOWAS Court. While the court is empowered to address human rights violations within its member states, claimants must fulfil specific legal and procedural criteria to establish standing and the admissibility of their claims.

The decision underscores the need for civil society organisations to carefully navigate these legal frameworks when seeking redress for human rights violations on behalf of affected individuals or communities.


The ECOWAS Court’s decision to reject SERAP’s suit on jurisdictional grounds is a reminder of the complexities involved in pursuing legal action against state actors, particularly in regional judicial bodies. It also raises questions about alternative avenues for seeking justice and compensation for victims of violence and insecurity in Nigeria, especially in cases where the state is perceived to have failed in its protective duties.


Justice Maryanne Anenih concluded the hearing by setting a new date for the continuation of the trial, marking December 4 as the next court session, following the vacating of the initially scheduled date.

Roland Bayode

Roland Bayode

Roland Bayode is a Nigerian journalist with expertise in investigative reporting and editorial leadership. A graduate of Mass Communication, he served as Editor-in-Chief of Echo Media at Adekunle Ajasin University and was the top intern at Premium Times Center for Investigative Journalism (PTCIJ) at Owena Press, The Hope Newspaper in Akure. Roland has contributed to News Round the Clock, PTCIJ Google-YIAGA LightRay Media, Apex Sport (U.S.), and served as Associate Editor for Nigeria Grassroot News under AFYMP.

Related Posts

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule
National

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule

17 hours ago
Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response
National

Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response

17 hours ago
Majority Leader didn’t break my head – Abia Assembly member Akachukwu
National

Majority Leader didn’t break my head – Abia Assembly member Akachukwu

17 hours ago
TCN announces power outages in Abuja, Enugu
National

TCN announces power outages in Abuja, Enugu

17 hours ago

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

NATIONS NEWS

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule
National

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule

17 hours ago
Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response
National

Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response

17 hours ago
Majority Leader didn’t break my head – Abia Assembly member Akachukwu
National

Majority Leader didn’t break my head – Abia Assembly member Akachukwu

17 hours ago
TCN announces power outages in Abuja, Enugu
National

TCN announces power outages in Abuja, Enugu

17 hours ago
PDP Has No Chance in 2027, Says Former APC Treasurer
National

Forum of APC chairmen want life membership of party’s NEC

17 hours ago
Peter Obi, El-Rufai Granted Waiver Ahead 2027 Election
National

Stop clamping down opposition over alleged coup plot – ADC tells FG

2 days ago

POLITICS

Peter Obi, El-Rufai Granted Waiver Ahead 2027 Election

Stop clamping down opposition over alleged coup plot – ADC tells FG

2 days ago
Some southeast politicians, businessmen prefer Nnamdi Kanu’s continued detention — Iwuanyanwu

Some southeast politicians, businessmen prefer Nnamdi Kanu’s continued detention — Iwuanyanwu

2 days ago
At my level, I can’t secretly defect to APC — Suswam

At my level, I can’t secretly defect to APC — Suswam

3 days ago
Arewa group lambast PDP Spokesperson over disrespectful comments on Ugwuanyi

Arewa group lambast PDP Spokesperson over disrespectful comments on Ugwuanyi

5 days ago
2027: Murray-Bruce defection to APC not surprising – Dele Momodu

2027: Murray-Bruce defection to APC not surprising – Dele Momodu

5 days ago
Breaking News: Former vice president Atiku Abubakar resigns from PDP

Atiku’s greed cause of PDP’s gradual demise

6 days ago

YOUR ECONOMY

Dangote Refinery Boosts Fuel Supply as Petrol Price in Nigeria Rises to ₦955 Per Litre
Economy

Fuel price drops as marketers resume loading at Dangote Refinery

2 days ago
Dangote Refinery Boosts Fuel Supply as Petrol Price in Nigeria Rises to ₦955 Per Litre
Economy

Dangote Refinery Boosts Fuel Supply as Petrol Price in Nigeria Rises to ₦955 Per Litre

1 week ago
Dangote Refinery Begins Distribution of Petrol Nationwide
Economy

We never imported bad fuel – Dangote Refinery

2 weeks ago
Naira Appreciates to N1,465/$ as External Reserves Reserves Jump to $42.4bn
Economy

Naira Appreciates to N1,465/$ as External Reserves Reserves Jump to $42.4bn

2 weeks ago
BREAKING NEWS: PENGASSAN Declares Nationwide Strike.
Economy

BREAKING NEWS: PENGASSAN calls off strike

3 weeks ago
You’re scaring off investors – Senator Karimi warns PENGASSAN over feud with Dangote Refinery
Economy

You’re scaring off investors – Senator Karimi warns PENGASSAN over feud with Dangote Refinery

3 weeks ago

E & P

2026 World Cup qualifying play-offs: We are ready for Nigeria – Gabon coach
Sports

2026 World Cup qualifying play-offs: We are ready for Nigeria – Gabon coach

by Steven Atogi
6 days ago
0

The national team coach of Gabon, Thierry Mouyouma, has said that his team is ready to tackle Nigeria in the...

2026 World Cup playoffs: Super Eagles likely to play Gabon

2026 World Cup playoffs: Super Eagles likely to play Gabon

1 week ago
EPL: They’ll be beaten – Paul Scholes predicts winner in Liverpool vs Man Utd

EPL: They’ll be beaten – Paul Scholes predicts winner in Liverpool vs Man Utd

2 weeks ago
EPL: Amorim should use Mbeumo as striker over Sesko — Owen

EPL: Amorim should use Mbeumo as striker over Sesko — Owen

3 weeks ago
Xavi Hernandez hinted to replace Ruben Amorim at Old Trafford

Xavi Hernandez hinted to replace Ruben Amorim at Old Trafford

3 weeks ago
Dembele wins 2025 Ballon d’Or ahead of Yamal [Full list]

Dembele wins 2025 Ballon d’Or ahead of Yamal [Full list]

4 weeks ago

YOUR THOUGHT & HISTORY

NASS Rubber-Stamp Tinubu: PDP Chieftain Blasts Legislature, Calls Akpabio ‘Unfit’
National

NASS Rubber-Stamp Tinubu: PDP Chieftain Blasts Legislature, Calls Akpabio ‘Unfit’

by Steven Atogi
2 weeks ago
The Union, the Tycoon, and the State: Dangote versus PENGASSAN War, A New Precedent for Nigerian Labour
Opinion

The Union, the Tycoon, and the State: Dangote versus PENGASSAN War, A New Precedent for Nigerian Labour

by Odini Brains
3 weeks ago
HOW MR EAZI, OTEDOLA’S SON-IN-LAW, BUILT AN 18-COUNTRY EMPIRE
Opinion

HOW MR EAZI, OTEDOLA’S SON-IN-LAW, BUILT AN 18-COUNTRY EMPIRE

by Odini Brains
2 months ago
Mr Eazi and Temi Otedola: A Love Story That Traveled Three Continents
National

Mr Eazi and Temi Otedola: A Love Story That Traveled Three Continents

by Odini Brains
2 months ago
The Rise And Fall Of Sports Institute, Isaka
Columns

The Rise And Fall Of Sports Institute, Isaka

by Tammy Opoki
2 months ago

Who we are

Umpirenews | Latest News, Politics, Breaking News, Nigeria and African history

Welcome to Umpire News, your go-to online newspaper dedicated to broadening perspectives and expanding the horizons of our numerous readers. Read more

Browse by Category

  • Columns
  • Economy
  • Editorial
  • Entertainment
  • International
  • National
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Trends

Recent News

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule

Supreme Court reserves judgment in PDP’s suit against Rivers emergency rule

October 22, 2025
Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response

Doctors strike: NARD to review FG’s response

October 22, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2024 Copyright Umpirenews. All rights reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • National
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Columns

© 2024 Copyright Umpirenews. All rights reserved

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.

🤑Join & Get Our Easter Gifts 🤑

Enter your NAME & Email NOW!!

Be among the 1st 100 lucky WINNERS to win our Amazing GIFTs this Easter Period as you READ our Daily hot NEWs & make meaningful comments and follow us on our social media handles.

Name
Enter your email address